Language/French/Grammar/Problems-with-passive-different-direct-objects
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Rate this lesson:
Problems in the formation of the passive arising from different kinds of direct objects
Most verbs which have a direct object will convert into a passive, but there are limitations to whether the meaning is sensible or not. Aimer can be turned into a sensible passive:
- Juliette aime Georges
Juliette loves George
- Georges est aimée par Juliette
George is loved by Juliette
but lire produces a less natural sentence:
- Je lis ce livre
I am reading this book
- Ce livre est lu par moi (???)
This book is being read by me (???)
Usually passives which make an inanimate direct object a subject and put an animate subject in a par or de phrase are unnatural.
NB: The verb avoir is used in the passive only in the colloquial “J'ai été eu” I have been had' in the sense of 'swindled'.